Difference between revisions of "Indicators"
From IMSMA Wiki
Line 179: | Line 179: | ||
* Average size of surveyed area | * Average size of surveyed area | ||
− | == References ==__NOEDITSECTION__ | + | == References (external links) ==__NOEDITSECTION__ |
− | * Participatory Impact Assessment: A Design Guide available at [http://fic.tufts.edu/assets/PIA-guide_revised-2014-3.pdf] | + | * Feinstein International Center: ''Participatory Impact Assessment: A Design Guide''; available at [http://fic.tufts.edu/assets/PIA-guide_revised-2014-3.pdf] |
+ | * World Health Organization: ''Monitoring the Building Blocks of Health Systems: A Handbook of Indicators and their Measurement Strategies''; available at [http://www.who.int/healthinfo/systems/WHO_MBHSS_2010_full_web.pdf?ua=1] | ||
+ | * Mikkel Nedergaard (DDG): ''Outcome Monitoring in Humanitarian Mine Action'', The Journal of ERW and Mine Action, 2014; available at [http://www.jmu.edu/cisr/journal/18.1/focus/nedergaard.shtml] | ||
+ | * Outcome mapping: TODO | ||
[[Category:NoPublic]] | [[Category:NoPublic]] | ||
− | |||
− |
Revision as of 13:53, 16 May 2014
This page summarises an initial, internal brainstorming on indicators.
THIS IS WORK IN PROGRESS! |
Contents
- 1 Principles for the development of indicators
- 2 Categories/Levels of indicators
- 3 Collection of indicators
- 3.1 Indicators mentioned in the Copenhagen initiative output document:
- 3.2 Indicators mentioned in DDG's publication on output monitoring
- 3.3 Indicators mentioned in the UN M&E framework:
- 3.4 Inspirational indicators from WHO document
- 3.5 Indicators mentioned in a discussion about operational efficiency
- 4 References (external links)
Principles for the development of indicators
From a presentation from DDG:
- Valid - Does the indicator directly represent the change it is intended to measure? Is the change within the scope of the project?
- Objective - Is the definition precise, simple and unambiguous about what is to be measured?
- Reliable - Is the data needed to measure the indicator consistent or comparable over time?
- Practical - Can data be collected easily, on a timely basis and at reasonable costs?
- Useful - Will the indicator data be useful for programme decision-making and learning?
- Owned - Do the local communities and programme management agree that this indicator makes sense?
Other approaches?
SMART - SMARTER:
- Specific
- Measurable
- Achievable
- Relevant
- Time-bound
- (Evaluate)
- (Reevaluate)
See [1]
Categories/Levels of indicators
This is just to have different sets of indicators, for different levels/purposes/areas...
- Output-level indicators
- Outcome-level indicators
- Performance indicators
- Impact-level indicators?
- Activity-level indicators?
Collection of indicators
This is an initial collection of indicators encountered so far in the mine action context. It is not yet an assessment regarding their applicability/usefulness/relevance!
Indicators mentioned in the Copenhagen initiative output document:
Outcomes | Indicators |
---|---|
Physical and Psychological Safety
|
|
Land Use and Livelihoods
|
|
National Mine Action Ownership
|
|
Indicators mentioned in DDG's publication on output monitoring
Objective | Indicator | Evidence to collect at baseline and impact assessment |
---|---|---|
Increase in productive use of released land |
|
|
Enable resettlement and return |
|
|
Improve access to markets and natural resources |
|
|
Do no harm |
|
|
Reduced violence and conflict |
|
|
Reduced threats from explosive remnants of war |
|
|
Improved security provision and conflict management |
|
|
Reduced treats from SALW |
|
Estimate number of firearm related accidents |
Indicators mentioned in the UN M&E framework:
TODO
Inspirational indicators from WHO document
Indicators mentioned in a discussion about operational efficiency
From a discussion between Helen, Rana and Elisabeth:
- % of areas worked on that had mines
- % of areas worked on that had UXOs
- Average size of cleared area
- Average size of surveyed area
References (external links)
- Feinstein International Center: Participatory Impact Assessment: A Design Guide; available at [2]
- World Health Organization: Monitoring the Building Blocks of Health Systems: A Handbook of Indicators and their Measurement Strategies; available at [3]
- Mikkel Nedergaard (DDG): Outcome Monitoring in Humanitarian Mine Action, The Journal of ERW and Mine Action, 2014; available at [4]
- Outcome mapping: TODO